Introduction:
For those of us who came of age in the singer-songwriter heyday of the 70s, James Taylor’s “Handy Man” (1977) holds a special place in our musical memories. This unexpected hit, nestled on his self-titled album JT, wasn’t your typical introspective Taylor ballad. Instead, it was a burst of playful energy, a soulful reimagining of a rhythm and blues classic that showcased Taylor’s versatility as a musician.
Originally a 1959 hit for Jimmy Jones, “Handy Man” was a swaggering boast from a self-proclaimed heartbreaker. Its lyrics spoke of a charismatic man who could mend broken hearts with his charm and affection. The song, co-written by the legendary Otis Blackwell, became a million-seller, a testament to its infectious groove and irresistible rhythm.
Enter James Taylor. By the late 70s, Taylor was already a superstar, known for his introspective lyrics and soulful vocals. His signature sound leaned towards folk and soft rock, a stark contrast to the raw energy of “Handy Man.” However, Taylor, ever the musical explorer, decided to tackle the song, injecting it with his own unique flavor.
The resulting version was a revelation. Gone was the braggadocio of the original. Taylor’s “Handy Man” was a gentler, more soulful interpretation. The driving rhythm and blues beat remained, but it was softened by Taylor’s warm vocals and tasteful acoustic guitar work. Producer Peter Asher deserves credit for creating a soundscape that perfectly balanced the song’s playful spirit with Taylor’s signature introspective style.
The song’s brilliance lies in its unexpected twist. Taylor doesn’t play the role of the arrogant heartbreaker. Instead, he injects a hint of vulnerability. His “Handy Man” is more of a caretaker, someone who offers comfort and affection to those in need. The playful lyrics, delivered with Taylor’s signature earnestness, take on a new meaning. It becomes an ode to the power of empathy and the simple act of being there for someone.
“Handy Man” was a surprise hit for Taylor. It reached number one on the Canadian charts and climbed the Billboard Hot 100, proving that his audience was open to his exploration of different genres. More importantly, it showcased Taylor’s ability to breathe new life into an existing song, making it his own while staying true to its original spirit.
Today, “Handy Man” remains a delightful anomaly in James Taylor’s vast catalog. It’s a reminder that even the most introspective artists can surprise us with their musical versatility. But beyond its genre-bending charm, the song’s enduring appeal lies in its message of empathy and the simple act of offering comfort. It’s a feel-good classic, a testament to the timeless quality of a good song, reimagined by a masterful musician.